Weird. The ending could have been so much better, makes the movie meaningless - except that there are some sick, twisted, creepy men out there.

Liam Neeson always good. Different story line. Good movie

stupid movie.. and to make it worse it took itself seriously and even thought it was clever.. so I'm glad it got panned by critics and didn't make money... hopefully they'll stop making trash like this..

Was Paul live or dead?? That last breath at the end really confused me. Got me questioning myself about Anna, Eliot and the kid. Me like.

what a actor Liam Neeson is.. great movie 8/10

thaw was pretty good but i still didnt understand the end

i enjoyed this twist but who knows if she was truly alive or not 7/10

I hate when movies end like this.

I just Don't understand this movie

wow that was crazy i saw the comments and was like "ill get this everyones dumb " confused the shit out of me so just 4 that 10/10 breathe while you still can WOW

NOT THE ENDING I EXPECTED BUT I SUPPOSE THAT'S WHAT MAKES A MOVIE GOOD

good movie but hated the ending i seriously want to puch out the people who made this movie end like this, I hope they make another movie so that creepy funeral gets whats coming to him !

Very good movie. Liam Neeson, as always, was amazing. It took me back to his time as Darkman. Ricci and Long also did very well in this movie. Justin Long seems to want out of his comedy type cast and he's doing rather well at it. The plot was fantastic, and I was sure on the edge of my seat the whole time. 4.5/5

So what was the whole message of the movie? I am wondering about the comments on this movie being good, and I think I missed the whole idea. Didn't enjoy it at all and am left with a creepy feeling at the end of it. I was waiting for a good ending I guess. Would have never watched it if I knew what it was going to turn out to be. It was also boring.3/10

good movie but sad ending 7/10

I liked this movie, def different, love justin long and christina ricci, great horror actors, i give this movie a 8/10....check it out.

Lame! LAME! LAME! Only because there was too many loop-holes. Christina Ricci was the only reason why I kept watching until the end. Liam Neeson was creepy and Justin Long acted like he does in all of his films, like a nerd. Great poster though.

its here omg... finally thanks..

both of them were alive

nice movie great acting, wished there was more action in it they could fit in much,worth to watch

I agree good movie and it made my mind up Cremation is all I can say lol

This was an odd one. Pretty good, definitely strange, kept waiting for it to twist one way, and it would twist another. Worth a watch. 7/10

4/5 it says Drama, Thriller but I think they should add Horror ~ Good movie. A lot of comments say they are confused, I don't know what there is to be confused about? If you don't understand the movie PM me. Good acting, Good Plot.

What don't you understand?

A very good movie. Exactly what I was expecting from the previews I'd seen - except that I was hoping for a more "supernatural" angle to it. Even though there were a few slow bits, it kept me wanting to know what was going to happen next. What a twist! *Wish there was a spoiler button so I can really get into things, but oh well...you'll have to watch it yourself to find out :P

Wow! This movie was awesomely borrrriiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiing, lol i wasted my time.

Very slow & confusing for me. Kept me wondering is she dead, is she not?? Hate movies which gets u thinking! Aaargghhhhh! 6.5/10

Love Christina Ricci (.)(.) !!!

5/5 one of the more interesting movies ive seen lately. kept me on the edge all time+naked Ricci:)and what exactly happend-who knows?:)

um, soooo were they dead alive befor the funeral or not ????